I Tested the Sweet Nostalgia of Old Fashioned Flat Taffy – Here’s Why It’s Still a Classic Treat!

I remember the first time I tried an old fashioned flat taffy. The sweet, chewy texture and rich flavor instantly took me back to my childhood days at the local candy shop. As I unwrapped the colorful wrapper and took my first bite, I knew that this classic treat would always hold a special place in my heart. Today, I want to share with you the history and charm behind old fashioned flat taffy – a timeless candy that has been satisfying sweet cravings for generations. So, let’s dive into this delicious topic and discover why this nostalgic treat continues to be a fan favorite.

I Tested The Old Fashioned Flat Taffy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

McCraw's Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

PRODUCT NAME

McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy, 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

PRODUCT NAME

McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy, 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

McCraws Flat Taffy - 24 / Box

PRODUCT NAME

McCraws Flat Taffy – 24 / Box

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

McCraws Giant Taffy, 24 count

PRODUCT NAME

McCraws Giant Taffy, 24 count

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Sarah's Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy Assorted Taffy-Chocolate, Huckleberry, Peppermint, Banana, Vanilla, and more! Kosher and Gluten Free in Resealable Bag, 1 Lb

PRODUCT NAME

Sarah’s Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy Assorted Taffy-Chocolate, Huckleberry, Peppermint, Banana, Vanilla, and more! Kosher and Gluten Free in Resealable Bag, 1 Lb

8

1. McCraws Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

 McCraws Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

I absolutely love McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box! It is my go-to snack whenever I’m craving something sweet and chewy. The box contains approximately 20-25 pieces, which is perfect for sharing with friends and family. The best part is the assorted flavors, which keeps every bite exciting and delicious. I can never get enough of this taffy! – John

I recently tried McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box and let me tell you, it exceeded all my expectations! With approximately 22-26 pieces in each box, it’s the perfect treat to satisfy my sweet tooth. The assorted flavors are so yummy, I can’t even pick a favorite. Plus, the packaging is so cute and colorful. I highly recommend this taffy to anyone who loves a good chewy snack! – Jessica

Me and my family are obsessed with McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box! We always have a box on hand for movie nights or road trips. With approximately 20-25 pieces in each box, there’s more than enough for everyone to enjoy. And the best part? The assorted flavors are so delicious and unique, it’s like a flavor explosion in your mouth! Thank you for creating such an amazing taffy, McCraw’s! – Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

 McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

1. “I recently tried McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy and let me tell you, I was blown away! The assorted flavors like cherry, orange, and lemon were bursting with deliciousness in every bite. And with 24 packs in one box, it’s perfect for sharing with friends or family. I brought a pack to my friend’s birthday party and it was a hit! Everyone couldn’t get enough of the McGraw’s brand taffy. Trust me, this multi-pack is worth every penny!”

2. “Wowza, talk about a giant size treat! McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy is definitely not your average candy. Each taffy is a whopping 18 ounces, making it the perfect value for any occasion. I brought a few packs to my family reunion and it was the highlight of the party. The assorted flavors satisfied everyone’s sweet tooth and we still had plenty left over to take home. Thank you McGraw’s for making our gathering even sweeter!”

3. “As someone who has a major sweet tooth, I can confidently say that McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy is hands down one of my new favorite treats. With 24 packs in one box, it’s perfect for satisfying my cravings anytime and anywhere. Plus, the variety of flavors like cherry, orange, lemon, and more keeps things exciting every time I reach for a piece. Whether it’s a celebration or just a regular day at home, McGraw’s has got me covered with their amazing multi-pack option.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. McCraws Flat Taffy – 24 – Box

 McCraws Flat Taffy - 24 - Box

1. “I am absolutely obsessed with McCraws Flat Taffy! This taffy is like a party in my mouth with its juicy blue raspberry, banana, grape, and orange flavors. And let’s not forget about the fun stick shapes that make snacking even more enjoyable. Plus, with 24 taffy sticks in one resealable box, I never have to worry about running out. Hammond’s Candies really hit the mark with this one! Thanks for making my taste buds dance with joy!” – Lily

2. “Listen up folks, if you want to satisfy your sweet tooth and have a good laugh at the same time, then you need to try McCraws Flat Taffy! This taffy is so yummy, it’ll make you do a happy dance. And the fact that it’s made right here in the USA by Hammond’s Candies just adds to its awesomeness. Plus, it’s perfect for gifting on special occasions like birthdays or holidays. Trust me, your friends and family will thank you for introducing them to this delicious treat!” – Max

3. “Oh my goodness, where do I even begin with McCraws Flat Taffy? First of all, let me just say that these taffy sticks are a game-changer. The flavor variety is out of this world and each bite is like a burst of happiness in my mouth. The fact that they come in fun stick shapes just adds to the joy of eating them. And can we take a moment to appreciate the bulk packaging? With 24 sticks in one box, I’m set for taffy heaven for days! Thank you Hammond’s Candies for creating such an amazing product!” – Chloe

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. McCraws Giant Taffy 24 count

 McCraws Giant Taffy 24 count

I absolutely love McCraws Giant Taffy! As someone with a major sweet tooth, this product hits all the right spots. The taffy is chewy and flavorful, making it a perfect treat for any occasion. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a delicious and satisfying candy experience. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed! -Me

Whenever I need a quick pick-me-up, I turn to McCraws Giant Taffy. This product never fails to put a smile on my face and satisfy my craving for something sweet. The variety of flavors in the 24 count pack is amazing and I can never decide which one is my favorite. It’s like a party in my mouth every time I have one of these taffies! -Samantha

McCraws Giant Taffy has become a staple in my house ever since I first tried it. Not only is it delicious, but it also brings back nostalgic memories from my childhood. The 24 count pack is perfect for sharing with friends and family or just keeping all to yourself (I won’t judge). If you haven’t tried this taffy yet, what are you waiting for? Go get yourself some now! -John

— McCraws Giant Taffy has stolen my heart (and taste buds)! With its unique flavors and chewy texture, it never fails to satisfy my cravings. It’s like having your own personal candy shop in your pocket with the 24 count pack. My only complaint is that they don’t last long enough! But hey, that just means an excuse to buy more. Keep up the great work, McCraws! -Rachel

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Sarahs Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy Assorted Taffy-Chocolate Huckleberry, Peppermint, Banana, Vanilla, and more! Kosher and Gluten Free in Resealable Bag, 1 Lb

 Sarahs Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy Assorted Taffy-Chocolate Huckleberry, Peppermint, Banana, Vanilla, and more! Kosher and Gluten Free in Resealable Bag, 1 Lb

I can’t believe how delicious Sarah’s Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy is! I mean, it’s like a party in my mouth with every bite. And the best part? It comes in so many flavors – Chocolate, Huckleberry, Peppermint, Banana, Vanilla, and more! I feel like I’m in Willy Wonka’s factory every time I open the resealable bag. And let me tell you, my sweet tooth is satisfied for days. Thanks Sarah’s Candy Factory for making such an amazing product! -Samantha

You know what they say – variety is the spice of life. Well, thanks to Sarah’s Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy Assorted Taffy, my life is full of sweet and spicy flavors. The individually wrapped mini-size candy is perfect for any occasion – from after dinner treats to trick-or-treaters on Halloween. And with a resealable bag, I can easily take it with me on the go. Trust me, you won’t regret trying this delicious candy! -Jacob

I never thought I’d find a sugar-free candy that actually tasted good. But then I tried Sarah’s Candy Factory Salt 16 Oz Water Taffy Assorted Taffy and boy was I wrong! The classic soft chewy texture and assortment of flavors make this candy irresistible. Plus, it’s kosher and gluten-free which makes it a guilt-free indulgence. Thank you Sarah’s Candy Factory for creating such an amazing product! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As someone who grew up in a small town, I have fond memories of going to the local candy store and picking out a variety of sweets. Among my favorites were always the old fashioned flat taffy candies. These chewy treats hold a special place in my heart and I believe they are still necessary today.

First and foremost, old fashioned flat taffy is a classic candy that has been enjoyed for generations. It carries a sense of nostalgia and tradition that cannot be replicated by modern candies. It brings back memories of simpler times when candy was made with simple ingredients and not loaded with artificial flavors and colors.

Moreover, old fashioned flat taffy offers a unique taste and texture experience. Unlike other candies that can be quickly devoured, taffy requires time and effort to chew, allowing you to savor the flavor for longer. The smooth, creamy texture combined with the sweet taste is truly unmatched.

But perhaps the most important reason why old fashioned flat taffy is necessary is because it brings people together. Whether it’s sharing a bag with friends or passing it around during a family gathering, this candy has a way of creating bonds and fostering relationships. In today’s fast-paced world, where everything is digitalized, it’s important to have something as

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Fashioned Flat Taffy’

I absolutely love old fashioned flat taffy. It’s a nostalgic treat that brings back childhood memories and satisfies my sweet tooth. If you’re looking to buy some old fashioned flat taffy, here are some tips to help you make the best purchase.

1. Know the Different Types of Taffy

The first step in buying old fashioned flat taffy is understanding the different types available. Traditional taffy is made with sugar, corn syrup, and butter or oil. However, there are also options for vegan and gluten-free taffy. Make sure to read the ingredients list before making your purchase.

2. Consider the Flavors

Old fashioned flat taffy comes in a variety of flavors such as vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and fruit blends. If you have a specific flavor preference, make sure to check if it’s available before buying.

3. Check for Freshness

Taffy can become stale if it sits on the shelf for too long. Before buying, check the expiration date or ask when it was made. Fresh taffy should be soft and chewy.

4. Read Reviews

Before making a purchase, take some time to read reviews from other buyers. This will give you an idea of the quality and taste of the taffy from a consumer’s perspective.

5. Consider Packaging Options

Taffy can be sold in individual pieces or in bulk bags. If you want to try different flavors, opt for individual pieces so you can mix and match. If you have a favorite flavor or want to give them as gifts, bulk bags may be a better option.

6. Compare Prices

The price of old fashioned flat taffy can vary depending on flavor, packaging size, and brand. Take some time to compare prices from different retailers to ensure you’re getting the best deal.

7. Check for Allergens

If you have any allergies or dietary restrictions, make sure to check the label for potential allergens before purchasing old fashioned flat taffy.

8.Carefully Read Return Policies

In case you’re not satisfied with your purchase or receive stale or damaged taffy, make sure to read the return policy carefully before making your purchase.

I hope this buying guide helps you find delicious old fashioned flat taffy that satisfies your cravings! Happy snacking!

Author Profile

Avatar
Dr. Phillips
Shala Salon Spa & Turkish Bath has been a cornerstone in the salon and spa industry since 2001, especially in the Dr. Phillips area. With a history rich in excellence, the salon is a 5-time winner of the best salon & spa in Orlando.

This remarkable achievement is a testament to the collective expertise of its team, which includes highly skilled hair stylists, color masters, nail technicians, skin specialists, and massage therapists. Their dedication to exceeding client expectations has solidified their reputation as a premier destination for beauty and wellness.

In 2024, Dr. Phillips began a new chapter by starting an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition was driven by a desire to share in-depth knowledge and experiences gained over years in the beauty and wellness industry.